Digger magazine

Serving the Northwest Nursery Industry for Over 50 Years

  • Digger-Employment_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • NG_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • FW_banner-2021-728x90px-1.jpg
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Nursery News
    • Features
    • Plants
    • Growing Knowledge
    • Operations
    • Nursery Country
    • Meta
  • Issues
  • Events
  • Farwest
  • Columns
    • Director’s Desk
    • Mike Darcy
    • Pivot Points
    • President’s Message
  • Employment Classifieds
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Plant Features / The value of the green label

The value of the green label

By Lloyd Nackley — Posted March 27, 2019

Survey tests whether customers will pay more, as well as which messages resonate the most

By Lloyd Nackley, Bruce Colman and Sharon Selvaggio

We’ve all heard it. People are worried about pollinators and want to do what they can to help. Some are planting pollinator gardens, taking up beekeeping, or choosing organic foods to try to help save the bees.

At the same time, many plant growers are recognizing that using pesticides can be risky for pollinators as well as beneficial insects.

Many growers are increasingly using biocontrols to manage plant diseases and damaging insects. Biocontrols come with the advantage that they don’t induce resistance, they are less likely to result in secondary pest outbreaks, and they can be more effective than traditional insecticides.

In addition, some retailers have made pledges to avoid plants grown with neonicotinoids, which have been implicated in bee health issues.

chartHow do growers connect these practices with customers concerned about pollinators? Few ornamental plants are sold with information conveying production practices. Organic is rare in the ornamental plant industry, so how do producers convey — and monetize — their environmentally responsible practices?

When it comes to selling plants, could an “eco-label” that signals pollinator benefits or environmental responsibility increase the price consumers are willing to pay? Can nurseries using biocontrol as a pest control method expect higher prices for their plants? What eco-labels result in the most market value increase, if any?

Until now, little current research was available to flesh out the answers to these questions. So, during the spring of 2018, Woodburn Nursery & Azaleas Inc., Oregon State University Extension and the Northwest Center for Alternatives to Pesticides set out to test these questions.

We surveyed 162 customers face-to-face in Oregon retail settings. Customers were surveyed at four retail nurseries in western Oregon (Fred Meyer in Milwaukie, Fessler Nursery in Woodburn, Cornell Farm in Portland, and Down to Earth in Eugene). Surveys were also completed at the Ag Fest in Salem, where Oregon Association of Nurseries attracts attendees with free plants.

Using lavender plants in 4-inch pots, we tested three different “eco-labels” and asked customers willing to participate what they’d pay for each eco-labeled plant compared to a lavender plant with a standard label sold for $5.

The three eco-labels tested were:

• Pollinator-Friendly

• Pollinator-Friendly and Grown without Pesticides that Harm Pollinators

• Pollinator-Friendly and Grown with Biocontrols

Customers will pay more for environmentally-friendly growing practices

Around two-thirds of the Oregon survey respondents said they’d pay more for a plant if the label indicated that the plant was “pollinator-friendly and grown without pesticides harming pollinators.” This was similar to the number who indicated that they’d pay more for a plant labeled as “pollinator-friendly and grown with biocontrols.”

In contrast, less than half of respondents would pay more for a plant simply because it was labeled “pollinator-friendly.”

The price premium of eco-labels may be significant

chartOn average, customers were willing to pay $7.01 for plants labeled as “pollinator-friendly and grown with biocontrols” and $7.28 for plants labeled as “pollinator-friendly and grown without pesticides that harm pollinators.”

Given that the control was valued at $5 per plant, this translates to a 40–46 percent increase over the base price. These production practices, perhaps perceived as environmentally-friendly, were more highly valued than the label “pollinator-friendly” alone, for which consumers were willing to pay $6.65, on average. The differences in valuation were statistically significant.

We found that the term “grown with biocontrols” was less effective, on average in eliciting a price premium than the phrase “grown without pesticides that harm pollinators.” Video taken concurrently with the survey reveals that many customers were unfamiliar with the term “biocontrol.” Attempting to gain a price premium by promoting use of biocontrol practices may require additional public education.

The 162 surveyed individuals represented a wide cross-section of income and educational demographics. Statistically, neither survey location or customer household income affected valuation.

Female customers comprised 63 percent of the respondents. Valuation was also not correlated with gender.

To see real-live customer responses to the eco-labels captured on video, visit www.pesticide.org/ecolabels.

Lloyd Nackley is a plant researcher, plant physiological ecologist and professor of horticulture at Oregon State University, stationed at the North Willamette Research and Extension Center in Aurora, Oregon. He can be reached at nackleyl@oregonstate.edu. Bruce Colman is a senior grower at Woodburn Nursery and Azaleas in Woodburn, Oregon. He can be reached at brucec@woodburnnursery.com. Sharon Selvaggio is the water and wildlife program director for the Northwest Center for Alternatives to Pesticides in Portland, Oregon. She can be reached at sselvaggio@pesticide.org.

Download a PDF of this article

Share this:

  • Print
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • Pocket

Filed Under: Plant Features Tagged With: Digger, Digger magazine, Marketing, Retail Nurseries

Lloyd Nackley

About Lloyd Nackley

Nursery Guide LIVE

Nursery Guide LIVE clicks into place

Booth spaces still available for Nursery Guide LIVE March 17–18

Nursery Guide LIVE virtual marketplace postponed due to winter storm damage

Keynote presentations at Nursery Guide LIVE virtual marketplace provide insight on green industry trends in 2021 and beyond

More Posts from this Category

CORONAVIRUS COVERAGE

Virtual is the new reality – for now

Trade shows in the time of COVID

A demand ‘renaissance’ for nurseries

Western Nursery & Landscape Association falls victim to pandemic

MANTS 2021 to move online due to COVID-19

More articles

NURSERY NEWS

USDA-NRCS Annual Report available for download

Two online lecture series available from AmericanHort

tHRIve webinar explores marketing by plant benefits

Suicide prevention program focuses on ag community

SBA disaster loans available for five drought-stricken Oregon counties

More Nursery News

FARWEST SHOW UPDATES

People’s Choice Award winners announced for the 2020 Farwest Show New Varieties Showcase

Augmented reality app allows New Varieties Showcase voting

Farwest Show launches virtual contest to crown 2020 New Varieties Showcase winners

MANTS 2021 to move online due to COVID-19

Growing with the industry: Farwest memories

More Updates from Farwest

From the pages of Digger

April 2021 – The Greenhouse Issue

March 2020

February 2021

January 2021 – Nursery Country

December 2020

More issues of Digger

Connect with us online

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
​

News

  • Nursery News
  • Growing Knowledge
  • Nursery Operations
  • Meta

Features

  • Plant Features
  • OAN Members
  • Oregon Nursery Country

Columns

  • Director’s Desk
  • Mike Darcy
  • Pivot Points
  • President’s Message

Resources

  • OAN Home Page
  • Job Listings
  • Subscribe to Digger
  • Advertise in Digger
  • Online Plant Search

© Copyright 2020 Oregon Association of Nurseries · Admin