Digger magazine

Serving the Northwest Nursery Industry for Over 50 Years

  • Digger-Employment_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • NG_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • FW_banner-2022-728x90px.jpg
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Nursery News
    • Features
    • Plants
    • Growing Knowledge
    • Operations
    • Nursery Country
    • Meta
  • Issues
  • Events
  • Farwest
  • Columns
    • Director’s Desk
    • Mike Darcy
    • Pivot Points
    • President’s Message
  • Employment Classifieds
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Columns / President's Message / The chicken or the egg?

The chicken or the egg?

By Leigh Geschwill — Posted March 1, 2016

OAN President Leigh Geschwill discusses the economic dilemma posed by raising Oregon’s minimum wage. 

Today we have an economic conundrum to deal with. Which should we do first: solve the true issues with our cost of living, or just throw money at the lowest level?

Like the chicken-and-egg riddle, the answer depends on your worldview.

If you know me you’re probably aware that I am an unabashed capitalist. I believe in the law of supply and demand. Our modified system of capitalism has created a tremendous amount of opportunity for individuals to innovate, to fill market needs and to improve their lives.

In our current labor market, there is a severe labor shortage — especially in the agriculture sector. This labor shortage spans entry-level, manual labor positions, all the way through technical and managerial staff. Oregon’s recent anti-immigration ballot activity and high cost of living further shrinks supply. The response to these conditions has been to raise wage and compensation levels — classic supply-and-demand leveling.

Given this scenario, wouldn’t raising the minimum wage fix the issue? Actually, no.

Raising wages for entry and low-level jobs just artificially inflates their value, and does not proportionately increase the wages at other levels. In fact, it creates wage compression, where there is less difference between the highest and the lowest paid employee. That would work great in a communist system, where being an individual is not valued or prized, and hard work is not rewarded. But in our country, most folks like to be rewarded for their efforts.

Raising the minimum wage also does not encourage your average American to go out into the fields and do manual labor. Let’s face it folks, this country was built on the backs of immigrants doing manual labor. Furthermore, a higher minimum wage does not address the issue of technical training and/or higher education that are needed for higher-paying positions.

By simply raising the minimum wage, we fail to address the more pressing issue of adequate labor supply for each level of worker our industry needs.

The second supply issue we face is a lack of housing. We have tasked our governments with managing our lands. State and local governments control zoning (where building takes place), density (how much building takes place) and, directly or indirectly, costs (what additional requirements or fees are required for building).

In a housing market such as the Portland metro area, where the average home price is upwards of $345,000, there is plenty of demand to encourage market activity. The argument could be well made that homes are overvalued — close to 70 percent of the housing stock under Metro’s jurisdiction is over 40 years old and in need of weatherization, efficiency and seismic upgrades. These houses should not merit full market value.

The need and desire for improving existing stock and creating new stock is real, but desirable units for rent or ownership are not available. The demand exceeding supply is rising at a rate that existing wage levels cannot sustain.

Again, wouldn’t raising minimum wage fix the issue? The answer is, temporarily.

Current wage policies do not address creating more supply, but simply act as an income subsidy. History has shown subsidies can be used as a short-term fix, but a higher minimum wage does not solve long-term needs. Nor does it ease government regulation and bureaucracy, which slow the development of an adequate, affordable supply of labor and housing.

In the long run, we need to address the bigger issues in our state that will improve the economic reality for everyone — not just take the easy way out with a temporary fix that leaves the real work undone.

Download a PDF of this article

Share this:

  • Print
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • Pocket

Filed Under: President's Message Tagged With: Digger, Digger magazine, Economy, Workforce

About Leigh Geschwill

Leigh Geschwill is the president of the Oregon Association of Nurseries for 2015–16.

The Value of Membership

Meet the Leader: Rod Park

President’s Awards Banquet recognizes vital contributions

Meet the Leader: Mark Bigej

More member stories

NURSERY NEWS

Six decades of support

Bailey hires trade communications specialist

Pursell Agri-Tech hires director of turf and ornamentals

Fall Creek hires general counsel

Oregon State hires dean of agriculture sciences

More Nursery News

From the pages of Digger

June 2022 — The Sustainability Issue

May 2022 — The Technology Issue

April 2022 — The Tree Issue

March 2022 — The Greenhouse Issue

February 2022 — Retail Outlook issue

More issues of Digger

CORONAVIRUS COVERAGE

Virtual is the new reality – for now

Trade shows in the time of COVID

A demand ‘renaissance’ for nurseries

Western Nursery & Landscape Association falls victim to pandemic

MANTS 2021 to move online due to COVID-19

More articles

Nursery Guide LIVE

Nursery Guide LIVE clicks into place

Booth spaces still available for Nursery Guide LIVE March 17–18

Nursery Guide LIVE virtual marketplace postponed due to winter storm damage

Keynote presentations at Nursery Guide LIVE virtual marketplace provide insight on green industry trends in 2021 and beyond

More Posts from this Category

FARWEST SHOW UPDATES

Tailored to today’s customers

Little Prince repeats as Best in Show booth winner

Two stand out at New Varieties Showcase

Retailers’ Choice Awards embrace discoveries at Farwest

Farwest marks a gathering of new, returning faces

More Updates from Farwest

Connect with us online

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
​

Updates to exisiting subscriptions can be sent to info@oan.org

News

  • Nursery News
  • Growing Knowledge
  • Nursery Operations
  • Meta

Features

  • Plant Features
  • OAN Members
  • Oregon Nursery Country

Columns

  • Director’s Desk
  • Mike Darcy
  • Pivot Points
  • President’s Message

Resources

  • OAN Home Page
  • Job Listings
  • Subscribe to Digger
  • Advertise in Digger
  • Online Plant Search

© Copyright 2020 Oregon Association of Nurseries · Admin