Digger magazine

Serving the Northwest Nursery Industry for Over 50 Years

  • Digger-Employment_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • NG_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • FW_banner-2021-728x90px-1.jpg
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Nursery News
    • Features
    • Plants
    • Growing Knowledge
    • Operations
    • Nursery Country
    • Meta
  • Issues
  • Events
  • Farwest
  • Columns
    • Director’s Desk
    • Mike Darcy
    • Pivot Points
    • President’s Message
  • Employment Classifieds
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Supreme Court strikes down most of Arizona immigration law

Supreme Court strikes down most of Arizona immigration law

By Curt Kipp — Posted June 25, 2012

Amid much anticipation, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its long-awaited ruling on Arizona’s controversial immigration law, SB 1070. Surprising some observers, the court ruled by a 5-3 majority that states may not attempt to supplement federal immigration law with rules of their own. The ruling is largely a victory for agriculture and other proponents of comprehensive immigration reform, who oppose the creation of immigration laws at the state and local levels.

SB 1070 had four major provisions, and three were struck down. First, the court ruled that Arizona cannot make it a state crime to be an illegal immigrant or to not carry proof of legal immigration status, because that would contradict existing federal law. Second, the court also ruled, for the same reason, that Arizona cannot make it a state crime for illegal immigrants to seek employment. Third, a provision was also struck down that allowed law enforcement to arrest legal immigrants if they believe there was probable cause the person committed a deportable offense.

What was upheld? The court did let stand, for now, a provision allowing police to check the immigration status of individuals stopped for other reasons if there is probable cause to believe the person is an illegal immigrant. However, many observers said that the court, in its ruling, signalled that it would reserve judgment on this type of provision until it sees how Arizona, and potentially other like-minded states, pursue enforcement.

You can download and read the full text of the court’s ruling in Arizona et al v. United States (2012) (PDF). Scotusblog breaks down the ruling in very clear terms here.

The ruling was written by Justice Anthony Kennedy, whom court-watchers consider the court’s main moderate swing vote. Joining him in support were Chief Justice John Roberts and justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Roberts is considered conservative, while the other three are considered liberal. Judge Antonin Scalia wrote a dissenting opinion on behalf of the court’s other conservative members, who include justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito. Justice Elena Kagan did not participate in the case because of her prior involvement in it. Before taking the bench, she worked for the Obama administration as solicitor general.

Share this:

  • Print
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • Pocket

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Workforce

Avatar

About Curt Kipp

Curt Kipp is the director of publications and communications at the Oregon Association of Nurseries, and the editor of Digger magazine.

CORONAVIRUS COVERAGE

Trade shows in the time of COVID

A demand ‘renaissance’ for nurseries

Western Nursery & Landscape Association falls victim to pandemic

MANTS 2021 to move online due to COVID-19

Nor Cal trade show canceled due to COVID-19

Reflections on Farwest

More articles

NURSERY NEWS

McHutchison and Vaughan’s Horticulture appoints new leadership, sales team

Friends of Nurseries awards announced by OAN

Oregon Garden Foundation reclaims management role

Zielinski appointed to state board of ag

Disaster loans available for drought-stricken nurseries

More Nursery News

FARWEST SHOW UPDATES

People’s Choice Award winners announced for the 2020 Farwest Show New Varieties Showcase

Augmented reality app allows New Varieties Showcase voting

Farwest Show launches virtual contest to crown 2020 New Varieties Showcase winners

MANTS 2021 to move online due to COVID-19

Growing with the industry: Farwest memories

More Updates from Farwest

From the pages of Digger

January 2021 – Nursery Country

December 2020

The Transportation Issue — November 2020

The Advocacy Issue: October 2020

September 2020

August 2020 — Farwest Edition

More issues of Digger

Connect with us online

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
​

News

  • Nursery News
  • Growing Knowledge
  • Nursery Operations
  • Meta

Features

  • Plant Features
  • OAN Members
  • Oregon Nursery Country

Columns

  • Director’s Desk
  • Mike Darcy
  • Pivot Points
  • President’s Message

Resources

  • OAN Home Page
  • Job Listings
  • Subscribe to Digger
  • Advertise in Digger
  • Online Plant Search

© Copyright 2020 Oregon Association of Nurseries · Admin